Crystal Temptations is recalling five package configurations of its Chocolatey Eyeballs Halloween candy after the product was found to contain milk that is not declared on the label. The recall was announced September 1, 2026. No illnesses have been reported. The candy was sold at Marshalls, TJ Maxx, HomeGoods, and Sierra Trading Post locations across 13 states. With Halloween season now underway, this product is likely actively on shelves and in shopping carts.
What’s Being Recalled?
Five package styles of Crystal Temptations Chocolatey Eyeballs are included, all with undeclared milk:
Plastic bag with designed header card — 10 oz., style number 54040-CHEY
Acrylic box with designed paper wrap — 7 oz., style number 54077-CHEY
Round plastic jar — 10.5 oz., style number 58008-CHEY
Designer plastic pouch bag — 16 oz., style number 58089-CHEY
Plastic bag tied with a tag — 11 oz., style number 54083-CHEY
The candy was sold at Marshalls, TJ Maxx, HomeGoods, and Sierra Trading Post stores in Arizona, California, Connecticut, Georgia, Indiana, Massachusetts, Nevada, New Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Texas, Virginia, and Wyoming.
Why Was This Product Recalled?
The recalled Chocolatey Eyeballs contain milk — a major food allergen under federal law — that is not declared anywhere on the product packaging. Consumers with milk allergies who purchased the candy would have had no indication from the label that milk was present. Milk allergies can cause reactions ranging from hives and digestive distress to severe anaphylaxis, a potentially fatal allergic emergency.
What Should You Do?
Do not eat the recalled candy if you have a milk allergy. Do not return it to the store — refunds are not available at the point of sale. Instead, destroy the product and contact Crystal Temptations directly with proof of purchase to receive a refund. Contact Crystal Temptations at 516-576-5500 or email [email protected].
